Philosophy | Opinion
Let’s Talk About Performative Rationality
Social media has created a new type of conservative, the one who’s absolutely adamant that they aren’t conservative (until the mask slips)
Over the last few years, a curious criticism of sensible beliefs has cropped up.
It’s a buzzword among certain communities, one that’s used to dismissively smear legitimate grievances, painting them as dressed-up and ornamented self-interest. The criticism comes in the form of a single word, an adjective to be exact: performative.
During the George Floyd protests, those who took a stand against racism were accused of being performative. When someone denounces something obviously horrible, like racism or genuine Third Reich Nazism, they get accused of being performative.
The accusation serves several purposes at once.
It makes an ontological claim about the nature of reality (that individuals are always self-interested and that egalitarianism does not exist). But this doesn’t convince most people because most people feel egalitarian at various points in their lives, so it conflicts with their inner experience.
